top of page

The Importance of Getting Multiple Contractor Quotes

  • Writer: Jessica Allen
    Jessica Allen
  • Apr 22
  • 5 min read

Updated: Jul 12

Understand the Market Rate

Getting multiple contractor quotes for construction and excavation projects gives you valuable insight into the current market rates for your specific project. Multiple estimates will provide a good idea of the average price range. This helps you to identify quotes that are suspiciously high or low. Without this comparison, you won't know if you're being charged a fair price. It could cost you thousands of dollars in the long run.


Compare Qualifications and Experience

By comparing multiple quotes, you can assess the qualifications, experience, and reputation of different contractors. This ensures you select the best candidate for the job, significantly impacting your project's quality. Remember that the cheapest option isn't always the best value when it comes to construction work. Sometimes, investing a little more in a qualified contractor can save you money down the line.


Reduce Dependency Risk

Relying on the same contractors for every job can create a dependency that might not always work in your favor. Circumstances change, and your go-to contractor might not always be available. Their quality might decline over time, too. Having multiple options ensures your project can proceed smoothly regardless of individual contractor availability.


Gain Different Perspectives

Different contractors may propose different approaches to the same project. New contractors often bring fresh perspectives, innovative techniques, and the latest industry best practices to the table. These varied insights can help you make better decisions about your project and its direction.


Strengthen Your Negotiation Position

When contractors know they're competing for your business, they're more likely to offer their most competitive rates and terms. This competition puts you in a stronger position to negotiate important aspects of the project including timeline, materials, and price. You may secure better conditions simply by shopping around.


Person filling out an estimate form on a clipboard in a kitchen setting. Background includes stove and light wood cabinets.
Getting multiple estimates ensures the best value for your project.

How Many Quotes Should You Get?

Experts generally recommend getting at least three quotes from various companies of different sizes. This gives you enough scope to understand what's reasonable for your project. It also helps you identify the average price range. While more quotes can offer additional insights, three is typically sufficient to make an informed decision.


How to Compare Quotes Effectively

When reviewing multiple quotes, don't just focus on the bottom line. Here's what to consider:


  • Use a spreadsheet to compare quotes side by side. Include contractor name, total cost, breakdown of costs (labor, materials, etc.), timeline, warranties, and any exclusions. This organized approach helps ensure you're comparing apples to apples.


Pay attention to:

  • Detailed scope of work (are they all quoting on the same specifications?)

  • Quality of materials proposed

  • Timeline for completion

  • Warranties and guarantees offered

  • Previous work examples and references

  • Communication style and professionalism


Red pin flag on white surface with "RED FLAG" written in bold red letters. Simple, direct message.
Stay alert to avoid financial scams: Recognize the red flags before it's too late!

Red Flags to Watch For When Choosing a Contractor

Getting multiple quotes isn't just about finding the best price—it's also about identifying potential problems before they occur. Here are some warning signs to look out for:


Unusually Low Bids

A low bid should raise warning flags. While it might be tempting to go with the cheapest option, an unusually low quote often indicates the contractor may cut corners. They might use substandard materials or plan to add charges later.


Excessive Upfront Payments

Your contractor shouldn't ask for an unreasonable sum of money upfront. Asking for more than 15 percent raises a red flag. Most states allow contractors to ask for a maximum of 33 percent upfront. Additional payments should be tied to completed milestones, not calendar dates.


No Contract or Pressure to Sign Without Reading

If a contractor forces you to sign the contract without reading it fully, that's suspicious. They might not want you to understand the terms or to research them properly. Never sign under pressure.


Poor Communication

A well-defined design process ensures your project meets your practical needs and budget. If a contractor is vague, reluctant to answer questions, or slow to respond, that's a major red flag. Good communication is essential for a successful project.


Lack of Proper Credentials or Insurance

Always verify that a contractor has the necessary licenses, certifications, and insurance coverage. If they cannot provide proof of insurance, this could leave you liable for any damages that may occur. Never hire a contractor without proper credentials for your protection.


Safety Violations or Concerns

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has specific rules for safety in many workplaces, especially on construction sites. If you observe unsafe practices during site visits or the contractor seems dismissive of safety concerns, it indicates deeper problems with their professionalism.


No References or Poor Reviews

If they make excuses when asked for references from past projects, that is definitely a red flag. Reputable contractors should eagerly share testimonials from satisfied customers. They should also have a solid online reputation.


Unprofessional Behavior or Inconsistent Work Hours

Observe the job site at various times. What does it look like at 10 a.m. on a Monday morning or 2 p.m. on a Friday? If it’s unusually quiet, you need to reevaluate your contractor. Professionals maintain consistent work hours and demonstrate reliability.


Constant Turnover of Subcontractors

Most contractors employ regular teams of subcontractors they trust. A constant turnover can indicate problems with contractor relationships. It might also show that the contractor is seeking cheaper options to maximize profits.


No Structured Design Process

A well-defined design process is essential for ensuring that your project meets your needs and budget. If a contractor cannot provide adequate planning services, it's a clear warning of potential problems ahead.


Special Considerations for Evaluating Multiple Contractor Quotes for Construction and Excavation

Excavation and site preparation form the literal foundation of construction projects, making contractor selection particularly critical. When evaluating excavation contractors specifically, also consider:


Experience

Look for a contractor with a proven track record in heavy civil construction and excavation. Past projects and client testimonials can provide valuable insights.


Equipment and Technology

Ask about the equipment and technology they use. Modern, well-maintained machinery indicates a reliable contractor. This is crucial for excavation work, which heavily relies on specialized equipment.


Site Assessment Capabilities

Before excavation, experts must analyze the site and gauge elements impacting the foundation's safety and stability. A good excavation contractor will evaluate soil composition, drainage patterns, and potential environmental impacts thoroughly.


Conclusion

Taking the time to get multiple quotes and carefully evaluate potential contractors might seem like extra work upfront. However, it's an investment that pays dividends throughout your project. By understanding market rates, comparing qualifications, and watching for red flags, you'll be in a better position to select a contractor who delivers quality work on time and within budget.


Remember that the success of your construction or excavation project largely depends on the foundation—both literally and figuratively—established at the beginning. Choose wisely, and you'll build not just a structure, but peace of mind.


For further insights, consider reading more about the importance of selecting the right contractor here.

bottom of page